"Tuscany's T-bone must be Chianina breed, at least 4cm thick, grilled over oak charcoal and served almost raw. Asking for it well-done may result in refusal. This is reasonable."
About Bistecca alla Fiorentina
Tuscany's cathedral of beef: a Chianina breed T-bone, at least 4 cm thick (a 'finger of meat' rule), grilled over seasoned oak charcoal to a charred exterior and a cold, bloody, almost raw interior; seasoned only with salt after cooking, never before; eaten standing up at the grill if necessary; wine is Chianti Classico Riserva; negotiation of the doneness is not entertained.
Bistecca alla Fiorentina, a staple of Italy's cuisine
The Rules
The bistecca alla Fiorentina is Tuscany's T-bone at its most uncompromising: traditionally from the Chianina breed, cut at least four centimetres thick, grilled over oak charcoal and served rare. It is salted after cooking, never before, so the crust forms properly, and seasoned simply with oil and pepper. The thickness, a finger of meat, is part of the definition.
The Chianina
The Chianina is one of the world's oldest and largest cattle breeds, native to the valleys of Tuscany, and its lean, flavourful beef is central to the dish. The cut is taken thick precisely so it can char outside while staying cold and red within. Quality of breed and cut, not seasoning, carries the steak.
Cooked Over Oak
The steak is grilled over glowing oak or olive-wood charcoal, seared hard on each side and stood on the bone to finish. The aim is a dark, smoky crust over a near-raw interior, cooked fast and rested briefly. The bone itself is prized, and leaving meat on it is considered a waste.
A Tuscan Tradition
Asking for a Fiorentina cooked beyond rare is, to a Tuscan, a refusal of the dish, and a serious restaurant may decline to serve it that way. There is no well-done version that is still the same thing. Shared between two or more and eaten al sangue, with a glass of Chianti, it is the heart of Tuscan grill cooking.
What to Expect
The bistecca arrives on a wooden board still sizzling from the grill. The surface is charred and slightly dark. When cut, the interior is cold and red. The first piece is eaten without condiment. The charcoal flavour and the beef quality are both immediately apparent in this initial bite.
Why Try It
Bistecca alla Fiorentina is Tuscany's most uncompromising dish. There is no modified version that is still the dish.
✦ Photo Gallery
Insider Tips
Buca Mario (Florence's oldest restaurant) and Trattoria Mario serve reliable versions.
Order it al sangue (raw to rare). This is not a preference. It's the dish.
The bone is the best part. Leave no meat on it.
